Solar & Battery Regulation & Incentive Programs

Energy Efficiency Resource Standard

Program Overview


Category:
Regulatory Policy
Program Type:
Energy Efficiency Resource Standard
Implementing Sector:
State
State:
Rhode Island
Eligible Storage Technologies:
Yes; specific technologies not identified
Website:
http://www.ripuc.org/utilityinfo/electric.html
Electric Sales Reduction:
Varies annually (see entry)
Electric Peak Demand Reduction:
Varies annually for winter and summer
Natural Gas Sales Reduction:
Varies annually (see entry)
Applicable Sectors:
Investor-Owned Utility, Municipal Utilities, Cooperative Utilities
Utility:
The Narragansett Electric Co
Last Updated:
03/20/2015

Summary

Origin

Rhode Island enacted legislation in 2006 requiring the state Public Utilities Commission (PUC) to establish standards for system reliability, energy efficiency and conservation procurement, including standards for energy supply diversification, distributed generation, demand response, and "prudent and reliable" energy efficiency and energy conservation measures. 

Additional legislation enacted in June 2012 (H.B. 8233) requires utilities to support the installation of efficient combined heat and power (CHP) systems at commercial, industrial, institutional and municipal facilities. Each utility must specify in its annual efficiency program plan how it will do so. Proposed plans must be approved by the state's Energy Efficiency and Resource Management Council.

Electric Sales and Demand Reduction (and Natural Gas Sales Reduction)

The specific standards and guidelines pursuant to legislation must be reviewed at least once every three years. In late 2014, the PUC adopted the following required triennial targets for its rate-regulated electric and gas utilities for the period 2015-2017.

Year Electric Energy Savings
(Relative to 2012 Baseline)
Gas Savings
(Relative to 2012 Baseline)
2015 2.50% (193,603 MWh) 1.00% (376,915 MMBTU)
2016 2.55% (197,475 MWh) 1.05% (395,760 MMBTU)
2017 2.60% (201,347 MWh) 1.1% (414,606 MMBTU)

The triennial plan also requires peak summer and winter demand reductions in the following amounts:

Year Summer Peak Demand Reduction (
Winter Peak Demand Reduction
2015 27,268 kW (27.3 MW) 27,268 kW (27.3 MW)
2016 27,813 kW (27.8 MW) 27,268 kW (27.3 MW)
2017 27,268 kW (27.3 MW) 27,268 kW (27.3 MW)

Each electric and natural gas distribution company must submit to the PUC for review and approval every three years -- beginning September 1, 2008, and ending September 1, 2017 -- a plan for system reliability, energy efficiency and energy conservation procurement.

Program Administrator Type

While the recommended standards and programs intended to meet the standard are initially vetted through the Rhode Island Energy Efficiency and Resource Management Council (EERMC), the seats of which are comprised of a representative range of energy efficiency stakeholders, the programs are administered by Rhode Island's affected utilities.

Cost Effectiveness and Program Evaluation

Rhode Island uses the Total Resource Cost test (TRC), one of the five "California tests" in the California Standard Practice Manual, as the primary test for evaluating the programs intended to meet the standard. 

Utility Cost Recovery Provisions

Decoupling and Program Cost Recovery

Rhode Island Statute 39-2.1.2 requires each electric distribution company to include a surcharge per kilowatt-hour delivered to fund demand-side management programs, which are implemented by the electric distribution company. The electricity surcharge took effect January 1, 2008, and will remain in place through December 31, 2017. Similarly, each gas distribution company must include a surcharge per decatherm (Dth) delivered to fund demand-side management programs. The gas surcharge took effect January 1, 2007, and will remain in place through December 31, 2017. The PUC determines the surcharge levels, which are not specified by the statute, for electricity and gas delivery.

The Narragansett Electric Company (d/b/a National Grid), Rhode Island's largest electric and gas utility, has its electric and gas revenues decoupled from its sales. 

Performance Incentive for Narragansett Electric Company (d/b/a National Grid)

In addition, National Grid receives performance incentives for achievement (and exceedance) of its electric and gas efficiency targets. The utility can earn incentives starting at 75% savings target achievement, and can be earned on a sliding scale basis up to 125% for both gas and electric programs. For annual program achievement levels ranging from 75% to 100% of target, the (relatively complex) formulas used to determine National Grid's incentive can be stated as:

Incentive = Total Program Spending * (15% x (The level of achieved savings) - 10%)

For annual program achievement levels from >100% and 125%, the formula can be stated as:

Incentive = Total Program Spending * (5% x (The level of achieved savings))

While natural gas savings are strictly measured on an energy (MMBTU) basis and not on demand reduction, the incentive is strictly a function of energy savings. However, electric incentives have separate electric energy and demand savings and demand savings components. The energy and demand components are 70% and 30% of the total electric incentive, respectively.

Given the complexity of the formula (and two-part nature of the electric portion), the first table below illustrate the maximum possible after-tax incentives for specific levels of electric efficiency target achievements, from 75% to 125%, strictly on a percentage basis.
 
Utility Type Max After-Tax Electric Incentive
Max After-Tax Gas Incentive
75% (Min) 1.25% 1.25%
80% 2% 2%
85% 2.75% 2.75%
90% 3.50% 3.50%
95% 4.25% 4.25%
100% 5% 5%
105% 5.25% 5.25%
110% 5.50% 5.50%
115% 5.75% 5.75%
120% 6% 6%
125% (Max) 6.25% 6.25%

This table shows the combined after-tax incentive totals for National Grid's electric and gas utilities, also on a percentage basis.
 
Utility Type Max Electric Energy Incentive Component
(70% of Total)
Max Electric Demand Incentive Component
(30% of Total)
75% (Min)  0.875% 0.375%
80% 1.40% 0.6%
85% 1.925% 0.825%
90% 2.450% 1.05%
95% 2.975% 1.275%
100% 3.5% 1.5%
105% 3.675% 1.575%
110% 3.85% 1.65%
115% 4.025% 1.725%
120% 4.2% 1.8%
125% (Max) 4.375% 1.875%